Close

Hack Chat Transcript, Part 3

A event log for Low-Cost Nanopositioning Hack Chat

The world's getting smaller

dan-maloneyDan Maloney 06/15/2022 at 21:290 Comments

Prof. Jim Brenner12:49 PM
You mentioned https://www.celeramotion.com/microe/products/linear-encoders/. Which ones are you using the Nano / Optiras?

Dan Maloney12:49 PM
@Prof. Jim Brenner - We had Zach Tong on the Hack Chat not too long ago, he's interested in DIY AFM

Hash12:49 PM
@mh-nexus If you click and hold the scroll bar on the right you can drag it up

Dan Maloney12:49 PM

https://hackaday.io/event/179336-microscopy-hack-chat

HACKADAY

Microscopy Hack Chat

Zachary Tong will host the Hack Chat on Wednesday, June 23 at noon Pacific. Time zones got you down? Try our handy time zone converter. There was a time when electronics was very much a hobby that existed in the macroscopic world.

Read this on Hackaday

Prof. Jim Brenner12:50 PM
I saw that you referenced a company selling your AFM's. Only $3 K! At that price, I think I'll buy one as a backup. I assume you get a royalty.

Dan Maloney12:50 PM
Might want to check that out, and his YT channel is pretty cool too

Edwin Hwu12:50 PM

https://www.stromlinet-nano.org/

MY SITE

Stromlinet Nano - Nanoscience Made Easy

Read this on My Site

Edwin Hwu12:50 PM
@Dan Maloney thanks! ;p

Edwin Hwu12:50 PM

Edwin Hwu12:51 PM
@Prof. Jim Brenner yes, I get 10% my institute get 90% XDDDDD

Prof. Jim Brenner12:51 PM
I went to the site, but I hadn't gotten to the pricing yet. Would you like the Stromlinet Nano to be featured in my textbook?

Edwin Hwu12:51 PM
I think you can ask them....also your text book can cite the Nature nanotechnology article

Edwin Hwu12:52 PM

https://www.nature.com/articles/nnano.2015.95

NATURE

Creativity unleashed - Nature Nanotechnology

Hands-on challenges such as building a low-cost atomic force microscope for schools can teach more than standard lessons, says François Grey. When I arrived as a visiting professor at Tsinghua University in 2008, one of my first tasks was to set up an international summer school that would expose foreign students to the many exciting advances being made in China in the field of nanotechnology, and to encourage them to collaborate with their Chinese counterparts on practical projects.

Read this on Nature

mh-nexus12:52 PM
@Edwin Hwu Maybe someone asked the question already but I couldnt find a mention of this in the chat. What medical applications do you see, since the devices will be too bulky to work inside the human body.

polyfractal12:53 PM
(Hiya, I'm Breaking Taps :) )

That's cool you're the tech behind the stromlinet system! Didn't realize they had licensed that from you

Edwin Hwu12:54 PM
@mh-nexus I think electrode implant for brain machine interface can be a good application for nanopositioner ;)

Edwin Hwu12:54 PM
@polyfractal did you have one? ;p

Edwin Hwu12:55 PM

polyfractal12:55 PM
I don't, but I looked at them for a whlie when thinking about AFM systems (either commercially or DIY)

Prof. Jim Brenner12:55 PM
I made enough money off of my companies that I don't need to beg for $ any more. I will definitely ask about the nature nanotech article and the Stromlinet Nano site. I have been in charge of a nanotech minor since 2004. We have been using the Nanosurfs, originally available via Nanoscience Instruments. You may want to browse some of the folders at https://fit.instructure.com/courses/265730/files for training videos.

Edwin Hwu12:55 PM
This AFM use piezo buzzers for high resolution scanning, super low cost ;3

Hash12:55 PM
@polyfractal Nice YouTube channel, look forward to checking out your content later tonight

polyfractal12:55 PM
😊 thanks!

Edwin Hwu12:56 PM

https://www.youtube.com/c/EdwinHwuHacks4Science/videos

YOUTUBE

Edwin Hwu

Associate Professor at IDUN Research Group. Hardware hacking as an unorthodox way of research. Co-Founder of BluSense Diagnostics.

Read this on YouTube

Edwin Hwu12:56 PM
This is my channel ;p

placethesundontshine12:57 PM
Is the Espresso AFM a different design?

Prof. Jim Brenner12:57 PM
Thanks @Dan Maloney. I have used Hackaday's site, but this is the first time I had time for chats.

Joachim Fischer12:57 PM
do you think you will be able to publish/open-source the rotary dseign any time soon? That looks super intersting to me...

Dan Maloney12:57 PM
Good stuff on your Hackaday.io page, too:

Dan Maloney12:57 PM

https://hackaday.io/whoand

Merijn Otterman12:57 PM
would it be possible to use the self mixing of a laser diode for low cost feedback for a nano or submicron positioner? I imagine at least the drifting of the frequency will be an issue? Seems that it could be a very low cost solution.

Edwin Hwu12:57 PM
Espresso AFM use the same mechanism like DIY AFM...only the tip alignment is done by rotary piezo motor ;p

Hash12:58 PM
@Edwin Hwu +1 Subscribers ;)

lageos12:58 PM
Hi sorry for joining late :(

How much does simulation play a role or would make sense in your opinion? Had some nice results with open source software (openCFS https://www.opencfs.org/ ).

Edwin Hwu12:58 PM
@Merijn Otterman that's possible...we can use interal photodiode of laser diode to read interference signal

Edwin Hwu12:59 PM
@lageos thanks! I am not sure...maybe stick slip simulation? :)

Edwin Hwu12:59 PM
@Hash thanks! :D

polyfractal12:59 PM
kinda related question, how much variability is there between different piezo chips? Not a problem if/when an encoder is added, but running open loop do they have fairly similar step size?

mh-nexus12:59 PM
@Edwin Hwu Are you aware of something regarding nanorobotics or microrobotics combined with imaging that could be doable outside of a highly specialized uni lab?

Edwin Hwu1:01 PM
@polyfractal the forward and backward positioning has slightly difference...because piezo expansion and contraction have different speed...

Edwin Hwu1:02 PM
@mh-nexus I think microrobits has higher chance....because nano one needs SEM or other microscopy to see :)

polyfractal1:02 PM
Hm interesting. I wonder if it could be preloaded slightly in one direction to counteract that? Might be too hard given the size of motion here. Encoder would definitely be easier :)

Edwin Hwu1:03 PM
@polyfractal smart! Acutally I did put spring preload...but I didn't mention in the paper because I would like to KISS (Keep it simple and stupid) :D

Dan Maloney1:03 PM
Welp, that's our hour! It was a fast one -- lots of great discussion. I want to thank Edwin for stopping by today, I really enjoyed this Chat. And thanks to all of you out there for the great questions and all the discussion. I think we might have got some good collaborations started today!

polyfractal1:03 PM
ahhh, makes sense!

Prof. Jim Brenner1:03 PM
Yes, @Merijn Otterman and @Edwin Hwu. You can use the internal photodiode of laser diode to read the interference signal. To make sure I am lined up in X and Y, when I do nanopositioning, I raise my stage up one step in Z, then to make sure that I am dead set on my X and Y origins, I shine lasers at a bullseye on the other sides of the stage and then use the piezoelectric motors to correct for any X-Y positioning errors. Long term, the goal of this is to put together a nanoprecise bioprinter, and the goal is to make sure that the registry is perfect.

James Finch1:03 PM
@Edwin Hwu Awesome, I got hear in time! You have the DIY AFM on Instructable and two projects on hackaday.io. Any plans for more?

lageos1:03 PM
@Edwin Hwu Regarding stick slip: First yes that would be nice but tricky, secondly did you measure repeatability on the steps on your actuator design? What about wear on the (nickel?) plating on the magnet.

Dan Maloney1:04 PM
Here's hoping the discussion continues. Feel free to use Hackaday.io to keep things going

Dan Maloney1:04 PM
I'll wait a bit before I pull a transcript -- looks like there's still some chatting to do ;-)

Prof. Jim Brenner1:05 PM
The stick slip is an issue @lageos. This is why I use the laser interferometry and the piezoelectric motors as a correction. At each new level in Z, you just tell the G code to do an X-Y calibration.

James Finch1:05 PM
@Edwin Hwu Any thoughts on making a spectrometer using COTS parts that's cost effective?

Edwin Hwu1:06 PM
@James Finch I can try to put hacked Drone + Spy camer+Qi power for lab on a disc system if I have time ;)

Edwin Hwu1:06 PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBHWr2xoppQ

YOUTUBE EDWIN HWU

James Finch1:07 PM
@Edwin Hwu I've wondering about interferometry based maybe somehow with HD actuator.

Edwin Hwu1:07 PM
@James Finch I guess low cost spy camera can get you wireless spectrum meter ;p

Dan Maloney1:07 PM
Is there a link to the poster mentioned in the video?

Edwin Hwu1:08 PM
I can put the poster here ;)

Prof. Jim Brenner1:08 PM
For a really low cost spectrometer, try the one from Gaudi Labs. https://gaudishop.ch/ I use his spectrometer and his PocketPCR.

polyfractal1:08 PM
Gotta run, thanks for answering questions @Edwin Hwu! And thanks for the paper, very cool work. I'll give you a ping on twitter once I have some working prototypes of the stage, definitely interested in adding some of those encoders for closed-loop positioning :)

Edwin Hwu1:08 PM

MicroTAS2020_Poster Edwin M1-180.e.pdf
8 MB

Download File

Dan Maloney1:09 PM
Bye Zach! Thanks for stopping by!

Edwin Hwu1:09 PM
@polyfractal sure :)

lageos1:09 PM
@Prof. Jim Brenner Thanks fo

Dan Maloney1:09 PM
Thanks for the poster!

lageos1:09 PM
... for clarification.

placethesundontshine1:09 PM
Ah yep could use that cell culture monitoring unit for a side project we have with one of the local medical research institutes

Edwin Hwu1:10 PM
@lageos I didn't really measure the nikel thickness....since they didn't stop working ;p

Edwin Hwu1:11 PM
@placethesundontshine exactly, it's not easy to implement flow model for cell culture...but this cell culture on disc can do it in a elegant way

placethesundontshine1:12 PM
the project was on high throughput cell culture analysis for drug discovery

Edwin Hwu1:13 PM

Prof. Jim Brenner1:13 PM
The cell culture monitoring unit's microscope is quite good. I am putting together a 36-bioreactor tissue engineering test bed. We had put together a modified endoscope for each reactor with a blue-blocking coating (similar to Tac glasses or BluBlocker sunglasses) to cut down on the glare. Being able to view the cells in vivo means that you will no longer have to dye them and take them to an external microscope for validation. That is a big an accomplishment as the AFM work. Very well done.

Edwin Hwu1:13 PM
Recently I am writing a HardwareX article, to make lab on disc for everyone

Edwin Hwu1:14 PM

Edwin Hwu1:14 PM
@Prof. Jim Brenner Thanks :D I like this kind of fun development

placethesundontshine1:15 PM
Did you release a control bored/code for controlling the HOP-15XX units at all?

James Finch1:15 PM
Linear CCD vs 2/4K webcam vs spycam and having thoughts of sensitivity and refresh rates. Though kind of a more narrow time very dynamic situation vs static sample.

Edwin Hwu1:15 PM
@placethesundontshine HOP-15xx? I didn't use this head before...

Prof. Jim Brenner1:16 PM
The WiFi spy camera is similar to a project one of the groups in my Basics of Making class this summer is doing. https://fit.instructure.com/courses/604044 is a "quasi-syllabus" for the course. I am adding a lot of content to make the management of the projects go more smoothly.

Edwin Hwu1:16 PM
@James Finch do you mean lab on disc imaging?

Edwin Hwu1:19 PM
@Prof. Jim Brenner is that link your teaching material? cool :)

michael.courtney joined  the room.1:20 PM

michael.courtney1:21 PM
Is that 15 separate wells you have on the cell culture disk, and you take a picture as each well goes past?

placethesundontshine1:21 PM
you mentioned earlier that you were using the 7 axis controller for manipulating graphene. Was that a successful approach?

Edwin Hwu1:21 PM

James Finch1:22 PM
@Edwin Hwu More-so just a thought and not specific application other than possibly standalone or microscope. I need to study the lab on disc imaging more as I'm only familiar with your CD/DVD/BluRay parts use and DIY AFM when you presented initially. I need to read into your work more... wow... you've really been jamming on the nanopositioning I've seen recently.

Prof. Jim Brenner1:22 PM
A start on my tissue engineering test bed work is at this link: https://fit.instructure.com/files/45147969/download?download_frd=1 and this one: https://fit.instructure.com/files/45147629/download?download_frd=1. Progress on my nanopositioning system are at https://fit.instructure.com/files/45607615/download?download_frd=1. Yes, that was my teaching material.

Edwin Hwu1:22 PM
@placethesundontshine I made the 7axes manipulator, but my colleague didn't get his project funded :(

Edwin Hwu1:23 PM
@James Finch haha...that's part of my "research advtisement" ;p

michael.courtney1:24 PM
Ah, I mean 16 wells. Could it be scaled to the usual cell culture sizes - 96, higher?

Edwin Hwu1:25 PM

Discussions