TWO SDRAM stciks break at the same time ?

Yann Guidon / YGDES wrote 06/24/2016 at 13:25 0 points

Dear hacking friends, I have an important question:
Today I turned the PC on (HP EliteBook 2540p). It wouldn't boot, beyond the GRUB prompt. I
run the BIOS diagnostic tools and it froze : it's a HW problem.
I swapped the 2 DDR SDRAM and no change: hard problems.
Fortunately I have a spare computer with original memory sticks (2×2GB vs the newer 2×8GB). The computers work with the 2GB sticks but BOTH 8GB sticks fail (alone or together) !

How can one explain that ?
I can understand that one fails but two at the same moment ?

The only scenario I can imagine is tampering with the stick's config EEPROM through the I2C bus, by some sneaky malware. But I've not heard about this kind of behaviour.
My computer now works in "degraded mode" (only 4GB) and should work today but I'm worried. I'm not able to dump the EEPROM to check it.
And it costs me money because 8GB sticks for this laptop are not cheap...

Other hypothesis : short circuit due to crushing on the wall of the laptop, against the naked shielding. But that can't explain why the TWO sticks  broke since the other stick is on the other side of the main board. And the motherboard is not affected.