Close

Environment sensor node - Sensor selection

A project log for CloverDroid : A Smart Urban Farm

A smart farming for cities using IoT sensor network, ESP8266/32, Raspberry Pi, and a small plot of unused land.

luckyLucky 09/28/2019 at 06:170 Comments

One of the sensor node for the smart farm is the environment sensor located on the top of the farm. In outdoor farm, environment parameter like humidity, temperature and light intensity is crucial since it can't be controlled like an indoor farm. There few existing environment sensor that available for DIY projects and here a few of them.

Temperature and Humidity

Few common temperature and humidity sensor like DHT11, DHT22/AM2302, BME280, BME180, and SHT31. DHT11 and DHT22 sensor is extremely cheap while BME and SHT sensor are more expensive. 

Some article provide a good comparison for these sensor like:

1. Adding Sensirion SHT31 to the range of test hygrometers.

2. DHT11 vs DHT22 vs LM35 vs DS18B20 vs BME280 vs BMP180

DHTs sensor is pretty good for common application that does not require precise sensor reading. While the error is not catastrophically large, the device does not support i2c communication protocol that I planned to use in this project. Moreover, DHTs sensor accuracy degrade quicker overtime when exposed to elements.

Light(Lux, PPFD, PAR, DLI)

The light sensor measure the intensity of light. In common climate sensor, the light is not a necessary parameter to measure. However, in farming light intensity provide the information that may able to help determine plant growth rate. Different from usual light meter that measure luminosity in lux for candela, light meter used to measure plant growth measure the PPFD or PAR. I won't be explaining the difference in PPFD or PAR compared to Lux as there are load of article explaining them already like thisthis, and this.

The issue with different measurement unit is that Lux and PAR measure different object response to light. Lux measure "human eye" light response, while PAR measure "plant" light response. While most article explain that it's NOT POSSIBLE to measure PAR with luminosity sensor like TCS3425, BH1750, MAX44009, or VEML7700,  that's true if the sensor is used to compare different light source like sunlight to LED light or some other grow light. In this case, the light source is the sunlight during the day thus it's POSSIBLE to use Lux or lumens to calculate PAR or PPFD. And thanks to Apogee Instrument to provide a comparison chart that remove unnecessary expense to buy an PAR or PPFD meter to convert my sensor reading.

The last question now is which sensor to use. TCS3425 is a RGBC light sensor, it use 4 different sensor with color filter to measure different light spectrum. MAX44009 and VEML7700 is a lux sensor with no filter. While an integrated "Lux sensor" is good enough, TCS34xx RGBC light sensor provide a larger light spectrum bandwidth which able to provide more accurate reading of "Lux for plants". Moreover, there is this research article that create a PAR meter with TCS34715-FN sensor (the same sensor family with TCS34725).

Discussions