Close

Different Power Sources

A project log for Tote

Affordable spider robot

dehipudeʃhipu 05/31/2015 at 14:172 Comments

Power source is a hard problem for any walking or flying robots. Unlike the robots that roll on wheels (or tracks), walkers have to carry its own weight, and the battery can be easily the heaviest part of the robot. They also tend to draw quite a lot of current for their many actuators, so that further limits the choices.

For the base Tote, I went with a single-cell LiPo battery, mostly because they have the best weight-to-power ratio, and they are relatively easy to get, either from hobby model shops, from electronics shops, or from discarded cellphones, electric toothbrushes, etc. but there are other possibilities.

Alkaline batteries are well known by the robot experts as absolutely the crappiest batteries you could use for your robot. Not only they are heavy, but also the current you can draw from them is almost nothing, and they will discharge pretty quickly, after which you can simply throw them away. So can Tote be powered with alkaline batteries? Let's find out!

As you can see, you can, but not for very long. But it's nice to see that Tote can actually lift them. That means that I could probably swap them for some NiMH or NiCd rechargeable batteries, and it would be all good. Let's see!

That actually went pretty well! Apart from some weight-shifting problems, I would probably need to find a better way of attaching them. Also, using AAA cells instead of AA would improve the weight, but unfortunately I don't have any AAA rechargeable batteries on me at the moment. Finally, a LiPo battery salvaged from a broken power bank, for comparison.

That huge battery should keep it going whole day.

Now, let's look at some more advanced hack. For an experiment with force-sensing servos, that I will describe separately at some point, I needed the voltage given to the servos to be constant, so that I would get consistent readings. The obvious solution is to add a switching voltage regulator (an UBEC), and I actually thought about that when designing Tote's printed circuit board, so there is a place for it:

It's conveniently located just after the power switch and the voltage-monitoring circuit, so that those two will still work correctly. One problem that I had is that this regulator needs higher voltage to regulate it down to the voltage desired, so I needed to use a battery with higher voltage. So I used a 2S LiFePo4 battery here. What is that? They are all the rage these days among the power flashlight geeks. They are similar to LiPo batteries, except they are much stabler both chemically and electrically, giving pretty good 3.3V voltage and not exploding if you as much as look at them funny. Unfortunately, you need a special charger for them -- the LiPo charging modules are no good.

Of course, for experiments on your desktop, you can always just plug the robot into a bench power supply, and have it drag a cable behind. It's actually more convenient than having to recharge or swap batteries all the time. Unfortunately you can't simply power this robot from your computer's USB. It needs way more power than the 500mA the USB standard specifies.

That concludes my experiments with power sources. As you can see, you have a lot of choices.

Discussions

Duane Degn wrote 06/01/2015 at 02:55 point

I'm sure you're joking with the statement "not exploding if you as much as look at them funny" but unfortunately there are lots of people who are afraid to use LiPo batteries because the fear they're not safe. I have dozens of LiPo batteries and I given them funny looks many times over the last ten years or so. I've had LiPo cells puff up or die if I've discharged them too far but I have not had any LiPo cells ever blow up.

I always use a proper LiPo charger and I charge my LiPo packs in a special fireproof charging bag. As long as people handle LiPo packs with common sense I don't think they pose a significant danger. As you showed in this project, LiPo cells can be a very good portable power source for robots.

LiFePO4 cells may be safer than LiPo cells but I don't think it's not fair to imply LiPo batteries are not safe.

  Are you sure? yes | no

deʃhipu wrote 06/01/2015 at 07:24 point

You are right, I guess it's a little bit unfair. Yes, putting a nail through a fully-charged LiPo pack will make it burst in flames and sputter hot toxic gel around, but it's really hard to do something like that by mistake, and all kinds of batteries will explode when heated up -- that's why they tell you not to put them in fire or leave in the sun.

People don't realize it, but we have LiPo batteries practically everywhere today: in laptops, cellphones, mp3 players, hearing aids, ebook readers, tablets, watches, portable radios, lamps, projectors, toothbrushes, mixers, doorbells, cameras, etc.

  Are you sure? yes | no