I ordered enough parts for my 3 OSH Park boards and worked on one last week.  I was pretty happy with the results, everything seemed fine and I was able to connect to the chip with I2C with the Bus Pirate but I was unable to get any pins to turn on.  I thought maybe I had a short and tried to re-seat the chip, but I think I may have killed it, I can't connect to I2C anymore.

I think I will abandon this board and try again with one of the backups.  I guess that's why they come in 3's.