Close

Joys of manufacturing

A project log for Stickvise - low profile soldering vise

Stickvise is a low profile vise designed for PCB soldering. This product was born on Hackaday.io.

alex-richAlex Rich 04/03/2015 at 20:570 Comments

I have been going back and forth over the past month working out some kinks in manufacturing, I thought I would share the experience here.

After the first round of samples, I noticed the nylon parts were displaying quite a bit of warping along their length as can be seen in the picture below. This isn't a major functional problem, but aesthetically I didn't like it when I closed the jaws together and they weren't quite flush, they basically looked like () or )( no matter what I did.

Warped nylon jaws

The reason for this is that the parts were too thick (exactly .25") and cooled unevenly after being molded. The golden rule of molded part design is keep wall thickness consistent and don't go above about 1/8" thick for most plastics. So why did I design the jaws to be so thick? Well I originally designed these parts to be machined, and when I ordered them I did a poor job of conveying that intent to the manufacturer. I sent a drawing, a CAD file and specified a finish, but never actually specified that the parts should be machined. Of course the manufacturer assumed for a plastic part I must want it molded. Next thing I know, I have beautiful molded nylon parts along with a nice little warping issue.

The manufacturer agreed to modify part of the mold, adding a hollow core to the parts as shown below (before and after).

Design for machining vs. injection molding

Now the parts are cooling evenly and are molding perfectly straight. In the end this will probably be for the best as injection molding is an inexpensive and repeatable process that will allow me to quickly churn out thousands of vise jaws if I need to. You can see the new part below with the bottom side shelled out and the top side which stayed exactly the same minus the warping.

modified jaws with cored out bottom

Discussions